It wouldn’t be unfair to say that just about everybody anticipated Shadow of the Erdtree to be good. I don’t assume there’s a single particular person on the market who’s going to be stunned if you happen to inform them the Elden Ring DLC is absolutely good. When the bottom recreation launched in 2022, it set new requirements for, effectively, simply just about the whole lot to do with video games as a complete, so when somebody tells you that the huge new chunk of content material that FromSoftware has added to that masterpiece can be actually rattling good- yeah, that’s not an enormous shock.
You recognize what is a shock, although? That in some way, regardless of the ridiculously excessive expectations everybody had heading into Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree, the enlargement is nonetheless higher than you thought it could be. Sure, on paper, it could be correct to say that Shadow of the Erdtree is extra of the identical. That’s additionally extremely reductive although, as a result of it fails to seize simply how way more of if there’s, how unbelievably good all of it’s, and the way successfully it’s capable of stand toe-to-toe with the seminal expertise that was the bottom recreation itself.
Shadow of the Erdtree is way bigger than you assume it’s. It’s roughly half as giant as the bottom recreation itself, which is much bigger than what FromSoftware mentioned pre-launch it could be, which implies even after pouring over 40 hours into the enlargement, it may nonetheless have loads of juice left in it to squeeze out. It’s primarily Elden Ring 1.5, which implies it’s far bigger and meatier than most video games you’re going to search out.
After all, this being a FromSoftware joint, what makes Shadow of the Erdtree stand out isn’t just how a lot content material it has on supply, however how good all of it’s. The Land of Shadow, the brand new map that you just discover within the enlargement, isn’t big a lot as it’s dense, with FromSoftware selecting to concentrate on vertical and intricately layered design within the open world slightly than one thing that stretches out over giant expanses. Mastermind Hidetaka Miyazaki mentioned within the lead-up to the DLC’s launch that From’s purpose throughout growth was to blur the strains between open world and legacy dungeons by way of how the 2 are designed, and Shadow of the Erdtree does that masterfully.
Exploration within the enlargement is, as such, immensely satisfying, to the extent that phrases actually can’t do it justice. There’s a bevy of shortcuts, secrets and techniques, hidden branches, and what have you ever in each nook and cranny of the map, and also you by no means know the place a winding path may lead you. There’s daunting and formidable dungeons to search out, vastly diverse biomes and areas to find, secret areas to bump into, and so, a lot extra. Simply as the bottom recreation did, Shadow of the Erdtree retains discovering methods to boggle the thoughts with its sense of scale, the ingenuity of its design, and the way cohesively and neatly all of it finally ends up getting tied collectively. It’s the type of factor that you just simply can’t discover in something not made by FromSoftware, with possibly a couple of, uncommon exceptions.
One thing else that stands out with Shadow of the Erdtree is how effectively it manages to lift the stakes on the bottom recreation in each manner conceivable. FromSoftware might have taken the straightforward manner out and made the enlargement geared in the direction of mid-game builds and nobody would have batted a watch, however Shadow of the Erdtree is particularly constructed for top stage, late-game gamers, which implies the overwhelming majority of the challenges that the bottom recreation will throw at you might be now not going to section you. What, then, might Shadow of the Erdtree probably have up its sleeve to make you’re taking pause, proper?
Because it seems, a complete rattling lot. Shadow of the Erdtree is crawling with enemies which might be going to stalk your nightmares for weeks to come back. Even among the common, trash mob grunts you’re going to run into are surprisingly formidable foes, whereas the roster of a number of dozens of minibosses and executives that you just’re going to tackle throughout the size of the brand new marketing campaign are going to place up the type of problem that’s going to make your blood boil. It’s, nevertheless, additionally tuned to absolute perfection, in a manner that solely FromSoftware can manage- problem that can push your endurance to its absolute limits, however won’t ever fairly really feel prefer it’s unfair, all of which makes the satisfaction of ultimately overcoming these challenges that rather more gratifying. Bosses and enemies in Shadow of the Erdtree are the proper mix of good recreation design and weird, completely inventive, and strikingly beautiful visible design. It’s FromSoftware it its very best, which is absolutely saying one thing.
Including to the added sense of problem and renewed surprise of exploration is how mechanically rewarding development continues to really feel, regardless of the truth that anybody enjoying this enlargement will very probably have already got clocked near 100 hours into the bottom recreation on the very least. That’s all the way down to the introduction of Scadutree Fragments and Revered Spirit Ashes, objects that you will discover and switch it at Websites of Graces to extend assault and resistance stats for your self and your Spirit Ash summons respectively, and these upgrades work solely within the Land of Shadow. It’s a superb manner of not solely making development nonetheless really feel rewarding and vital within the enlargement, but additionally making certain that it doesn’t break the late-game or endgame challenges of the bottom recreation itself.
It’s not usually that an enlargement is each good and expansive sufficient to be thought-about not simply pretty much as good as a full-fledged recreation, however even higher than the overwhelming majority of them on the market. In actual fact, that has virtually by no means occurred. Possibly you could possibly argue that CD Projekt RED has carried out it a few occasions – as soon as with The Witcher 3: Blood and Wine and as soon as with Cyberpunk 2077: Phantom Liberty – however that’s just about it- and Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree is a far, much more monumental achievement than even both of these two. Possibly it lacks the majesty and novelty of Elden Ring, provided that, on the finish of the day, it technically is simply extra of the identical, however there’s an argument to be made that the epic darkish fantasy journey it affords is as unforgettably spectacular because the one FromSoftware served up within the base recreation, if not much more so.
Sure, we’re saying that Shadow of the Erdtree is at the least pretty much as good as one of many biggest video games of all time. That’s how good it’s. It could not technically be an precise, standalone recreation, however it’s higher than the overwhelming majority of “full” video games you’re going to search out on the market. And no, that’s not an indictment on the standard of any of these video games. Shadow of the Erdtree is simply that rattling good. FromSoftware is a studio that has grown into the behavior of setting new requirements for the medium as a complete during the last decade and a half or so, and sometimes sufficient, that’s what the studio has carried out with Shadow of the Erdtree once more. Clearly, it’s unreasonable to count on that each enlargement for each recreation goes to be like this- and nor ought to or not it’s. The purpose, nevertheless, is that we now know that expansions can be this unbelievably good. Not that way back, even that thought would have been deemed unreasonable.
Observe: The views expressed on this article are these of the creator and don’t essentially characterize the views of, and shouldn’t be attributed to, GamingBolt as a company.
