Riven Review: Island Blues

Riven, just like the groundbreaking Myst that got here earlier than it, undoubtedly has an air of grandiosity if you first play, and never simply because it takes 4-5 minutes of loading and unskippable boot sequences to succeed in the title display on Quest 2.

Whenever you first load that iconic unique journey, past a gap cutscene extra for taste than steering, you’re left to discover the huge vacancy and thriller of the sport’s setting with out as a lot as a tutorial or trace of the place to start out. It was typical for the period, if not accustomed to fashionable sensibilities. Riven begins a lot the identical method.

We start in a darkish room, reintroduced by Atrus to the linking books that function portals to the totally different Ages. Within the Age of Riven, Atrus’ father Ghen has trapped his spouse Catherine on this Age, requiring that you simply enter this world utilizing the final of the linking books to avoid wasting her, and put an finish to Ghen for good by trapping him within the starry void between the Ages. There’s a number of lore to dive into for these most invested on this universe, however in follow, it’s extra of the identical: you’re dropped onto an island that serves as a grand puzzle labyrinth, tasked with traversing its many obstacles with a view to resolve its thriller.

With Riven, developer Cyan has rebuilt the sport from the bottom up with VR help in thoughts. Following the steps when remaking Myst, this remake is the primary time the pre-rendered point-and-click puzzle recreation has been painstakingly recreated and its island made absolutely traversable in 3D house. All puzzles have been painstakingly recreated as-is, albeit with some randomization to make sure returning guests aren’t immediately clued into the puzzle solutions with out placing all of the items collectively first.

What’s most instantly putting upon coming into Riven for the primary time is how tactile the island immediately feels with this bounce to 3D. Each button, lever, and extra can now be grabbed or turned and toyed with so as resolve puzzles and the deeper thriller of this uncommon place. Whereas some VR titles will scale back many actions to a push of a button, really being pressured to maneuver your physique to drag each lever and push buttons that affect the state of this world solely makes this world really feel extra actual, and these uncommon contraptions extra mysterious.

However when does thriller make method for obfuscation? Whereas far forward of its time when first launched, it is a query many newcomers have requested of Myst when seen from a present-day perspective. In that recreation, you’re dropped right into a mysterious island with out as a lot as a touch of the place to go first, an method that even lacks a tutorial for interacting with the world, which makes it off-putting to some. Myst’s broader simplicity as the primary entry has conversely allowed the sport to age gracefully; its uncommon method that may, on one hand, seem abrasive to newcomers, balanced by its contained nature to make it really feel manageable.

It avoids feeling overwhelming or frustratingly obtuse as a result of it by no means turns into so tough you are feeling pressured to depend on a information to work out what’s anticipated of you, which turns this preliminary ambiguity into one thing really distinctive. You’re feeling like an archeologist in the way you’re continually making new discoveries at each flip. Which is exactly the place Riven suffers.

Riven is broader in scope, an interconnected internet of islands and puzzles and a mind-bending starry expanse. Development means being anticipated to continually retrace by way of acquainted locales, meticulously making notes of objects not related till hours later as you attempt to monitor down Ghen. Puzzles are extra advanced, there’s extra thriller. As a setting, Riven is monolithic. Even by its ending, it seems like there’s extra to this place than meets the attention, and the possibility to lastly wander by way of it moderately than clicking by way of pre-rendered snapshots aids in speaking its scope and ambition. Utilizing its Magazine-Levs or strolling on foot is spectacular.

But it’s this complexity, coupled with the aforementioned points inherent to it and different puzzle video games of this period, that maintain this remake again. Riven generally feels too giant for its personal good, and I discovered myself annoyed on quite a lot of events, interacting with objects and not using a clear concept if it was having a fabric affect on the world round me or bringing me nearer to an answer. If I might even discover objects to work together with within the first place, a difficulty lifting Riven into 3D and VR compounds.

As with all good point-and-click title, a hard and fast perspective on a panorama will usually intentionally spotlight interactive parts with out making anyone answer seem too apparent to keep away from giving freely the answer to an undeserving participant. For as majestic because the recreation of Riven Island is in VR, this recreation comes at the price of the readability of the surroundings. At occasions, I might spend upwards of 15-20 minutes painfully working in circles, uncertain what to do subsequent. Not as a result of I used to be caught on a puzzle however for merely failing to note a tiny interactive panel, pipe, or button that its unique pressured perspective might a minimum of subtly trace in the direction of.

It’s points like this that bathroom down the expertise at a number of turns. Whereas the sport’s legacy already locations expectations upon it you have to settle for with a view to recognize it, at the same time as somebody who has accomplished Myst and its remake, I discovered myself pressured to depend on guides at its worst factors. It’s a recreation the place many puzzles require you to make bodily notes, a process made more durable in VR and never absolutely compensated for inside its in-game pocket book operate that means that you can screenshot factors of observe for future reference.

In the end, it strips the satisfaction of discovering options, or the reward in taking your personal path by way of an unfamiliar land. Irrespective of how tactile or detailed this world feels, if it comes at the price of readability or accessibility it turns into a moot level. I discovered myself extra happy once I let myself step again from the puzzles and stare upon its environments moderately than making an attempt to work together as meant, a world technically crafted with model however removed from the aim of the expertise.

Whereas the Myst remake has deserves that even newcomers can recognize, those self same sensibilities crumble when coping with a extra advanced world and expertise like Riven. As technically achieved as this recreation is, I reached the top extra glad it was over than appreciating the expertise I had.

Riven – Remaining Verdict

When Riven’s items click on into place, it reminds you of the marvel that gamers had with its unique launch, made solely extra spectacular by the very fact now you can attain out and contact it in any case these years. Cyan deserves a lot of that credit score, it did an incredible job in faithfully recreating this recreation from the bottom up with VR in thoughts. However the place Myst shined, Riven creaks underneath its age and such devoted recreation twists from a badge of honor to a burden.

In the long run, I got here away dissatisfied. A diehard fan of Riven might discover appreciation in its meticulous copy of a world from their recollections, but even then, it has points that maintain it again, a few of that are exacerbated by its in any other case profitable shift in perspective. Should you’re a newcomer to this world, the selection is apparent: as majestic as its world could also be, it’s tough to advocate.

UploadVR makes use of a 5-Star ranking system for our recreation critiques – you may learn a breakdown of every star ranking in our overview tips.